Judge Not: The Verse That Is Slowly Killing the Church

There was once a woman who went to the hospital with a small cancerous lump in her breast. The doctor, trying not to alarm her, brushed it off and said it was nothing serious. Months later, the lump had grown. It had spread to other parts of her body. By the time she returned to the hospital, it was too late. The cancer had eaten too deep. She died not because it could not have been treated, but because the one who should have spoken the truth to her decided to stay silent!!!

That is what is happening to the church today. A small sin shows up. A pattern of compromise appears. A cancer begins to grow quietly in our midst. And instead of confronting it in love and truth, we say: Judge not, that you be not judged. We silence every attempt to expose darkness. We label those who call out sin as Pharisees and ‘assistant Holy Ghost’. And so the cancer spreads. It eats into our pulpits. It takes over our choirs. It shapes our fashion. It redefines our marriages. It captures our children.

The saddest part is that this disease did not begin with us. It started in the West. They were the first to the best of my knowings to quote Matthew 7:1 out of context until preaching against sin became an act of hate. They softened their pulpits until truth became offensive and error became celebrated. Now Nigerian and African churches are walking the same road. Instead of learning from their mistakes, we are repeating them at double speed.

Also Read: List, But No Love

Wolves no longer bother to wear sheep’s clothing. They appear as wolves on our stages, and we clap for them. We invite them with tears in our eyes and honorarium in our hands. We give them platforms and celebrate them deeply because they carry influence. Sins that are clear in Scripture are now excused in the lives of ministers. Why? Because the church has bought into the lie that judgment is evil. And under our watch, the house of God is collapsing.

One of the most quoted verses in today’s world is Matthew 7:1: “Judge not, that you be not judged.” If you have ever confronted someone about sin or tried to lovingly correct a fellow believer, you have probably heard this verse thrown back at you. But the question we must ask is: Did Jesus really mean that Christians should never judge? Did He mean that we should close our eyes to sin, stay silent when people are destroying their lives, and allow immorality to flourish in the church? The answer is no. What Jesus condemned was hypocritical judgment, not righteous judgment. Judge not according to the appearance, but judge righteous judgment. (John 7:24)

That cancer patient we read about above might smile in relief for a moment, but soon the cancer will spread and claim her life. In the same way, when the church refuses to confront sin, pretending that “judge not” means silence, we are committing spiritual malpractice.

Jesus Himself said, “First take the beam out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother’s eye” (Matthew 7:5). Can you see that? He did not say ignore your brother’s speck. He said deal with your own sin first, so that you can help your brother in love and truth.

The real issue is integrity as against hypocrisy. If you are indulging in the same sin behind closed doors, then you have no credibility to confront anyone else. But if you have humbled yourself before God, confessed your sins, judged yourself, mourned over your sins and allowed Him to cleanse your heart, and you are daily walking on the narrow way, carrying your cross and following Christ, then you can correct someone else without hypocrisy. Self-examination always comes before righteous judgment.

And the truth is that if you are someone who constantly judges herself, you will most definitely do righteous judging. When you take the time to look honestly at your own heart, your choices, and your mistakes, you begin to understand yourself and others better. And by judging yourself, I don’t mean guilt or self-condemnation. I mean that ‘Blessed are those who mourn, for they shall be comforted’ kind of judging. You mourn over your anger till you receive comfort. You mourn over your pride, till you are comforted. You get yourself down in the ash every moment with humility and a willingness to let God show you the truth.

Also Read: What are you waiting for? Heaven or Jesus?

Once you’ve confronted your own faults and allowed Him to cleanse you, your words carry weight. In fact, God arms you with the authority to judge! You are able to see clearly to help your neighbor blow off the speck in her eye. You correct with love, not pride, and guide others without hypocrisy. Someone who never examines herself risks being legalistic, harsh, or even destructive. But a person who walks in self-awareness reflects God’s heart and turns judgment into a tool that restores, protects, and strengthens the people around her.

The truth is that a person who constantly judges herself has her eyes treated with the salve of God’s Word and her mind refreshed by His Spirit. She sees the rots, the compromises, and the decay in the church the way the Father sees them. And she is not meant to feel it and hide it away. She is meant to mourn over it, to weep over it, and then to sound the alarm. What good is a car horn if it cannot warn? What good is a streetlight if it does not shine? And what good is a watchman whose whistle is dead, whose sense of judgment is cracked, whose heart is numb to the danger around him? Her calling is to warn, to protect, and to guide, not to be silent while destruction spreads.

In 1 Corinthians 5, Paul rebuked the church for tolerating sexual immorality that was so shocking that even unbelievers were appalled. Instead of confronting the sin, the church boasted about their tolerance. ‘We don’t judge in our church. We accept everyone! Come as you are, remain as you are. Infect everywhere, no problem.’ But Paul’s response was sharp and clear: “Purge the evil person from among you.” He compared sin to leaven, explaining that a little leaven will eventually spread and corrupt the whole lump. So, in simple words, tolerating sin does not make you merciful, it makes you negligent.

Verse 3 says: For though absent in body, I am present in spirit; and as if present, I have already pronounced judgment on the one who did such a thing….

Recent Posts

Borrow More Vessels for the Overflow

Wholehearted: The Kind of Heart God Cannot Ignore

Launch Out into the Deep!

He under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit went even harder: 11 But now I am writing to you not to associate with anyone who bears the name of brother if he is guilty of sexual immorality or greed, or is an idolater, reviler, drunkard, or swindler—not even to eat with such a one. 12 For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Is it not those inside the church whom you are to judge? 13 God judges[c] those outside. “Purge the evil person from among you.”

Did you read God’s word well? Verse 12 says again: For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Is it not those inside the church whom you are to judge?

Ayaaaaa!!! Can you see the deviation of the church from the Truth? We have been long gone! Oh, we have long fallen! We have tolerated a few rotten tomatoes and now, the whole trailer is infested! What sin is no longer named in the church? Even the ministers on the pulpit can be involved in immorality, divorce, caught in one scandal or the other but we will continue there. We will cover him up because of a misquoting of the Word of the Lord Jesus Christ. Don’t you know that Scripture must never be isolated, treated alone, or twisted to fit comfort? We are called to compare Scripture with Scripture, measuring all things by the truth of God’s Word. As Paul says in 1 Corinthians 2:13, we are to speak and understand spiritual truths by “comparing spiritual things with spiritual.” This is how we avoid error, misinterpretation, and the dangerous twisting of God’s commands. Oh, how far we have strayed!

This is why churches must be watchful. A shepherd who only sings to his sheep but refuses to chase away wolves is not loving. He is careless. Protecting the flock sometimes means difficult conversations, discipline, and correction. It means speaking the truth even when it is uncomfortable.

So, Jesus never said “Do not judge” in the way we use it today. He said, “Judge not, that you be not judged… first take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother’s eye” (Matthew 7:1-5). The problem is not judgment itself. The problem is hypocrisy. He was not telling us to abandon discernment. He was telling us to practice righteous judgment.

You just imagine a man with grease-stained hands. His friend is wearing a sparkling white shirt with a little stain on it. Instead of washing his own hands first, he rushes to help remove the stain. What will happen? He will ruin the shirt completely. That is what Jesus meant. If your own life is dirty, if your heart is unclean, you cannot correct someone without messing things up. But if you have gone to God, confessed your sins, and allowed Him to cleanse you, then your words carry credibility. You can help your brother without staining him further.

We must understand that discernment and correction is not cruelty but love. If your child is playing with a poisonous snake and you keep quiet, you are not kind. You are wicked. If your friend is about to drive into a ditch and you smile and wave, you are not being supportive. You are being murderous. In the same way, silence in the face of sin is not mercy but hatred dressed in politeness.

Paul says in 1 Corinthians 5 that a little leaven leavens the whole lump. Just a little compromise spreads until it takes over the entire church. That is why he told the Corinthians to expel the immoral brother from among them. Not because he hated him, but because he loved the church enough to protect it from decay.

So we must ask ourselves: What kind of church are we building in Nigeria and Africa today? Are we watching cancer spread in silence? Are we mistaking cowardice for compassion? Are we more afraid of being called judgmental than of being found guilty before God?

The truth is that the world will always tell us not to judge because they do not want their darkness exposed. But when the church begins to echo the same lie, destruction is near. We are not called to condemn. But we are called to discern. We are not called to gossip about sin. But we are called to confront it in love. We are not called to throw stones. But we are called to bring light.

If we fail to do this, then wolves will keep multiplying, cancers will keep spreading, and the next generation will inherit a church that has a cross on its roof but no Christ in its midst.

It is time to return to righteous judgment. Not that judgment that comes from pride or malice, but judgment that flows from humility, truth, and love for God’s Holy Name and His people. For if we keep hiding behind “Judge not,” the same verse we use as an excuse today will become the verdict over us tomorrow.